Home / Blog / Agile Management; is still a mystery!
My Saturday morning is not complete, without me having my usual kadak chai (strong tea) at Sharvana Bhawan South Indian restaurant, right next to my home. They say; I was the first customer to enter their shop, when then opened the restaurant here, two years ago. I know most of the staffs and managers. Some of them run with me in the park during the weekend. There are two managers, who manage this restaurant.
One is very social, a very good friend of mine, runs with me, plays tennis with me etc. I know him for two years now. The other manager is very quite, reserved but not so social. He just does his job, that’s all. The manager who is my friend is travelling now in India and I was served this morning by the other reserved manager.
While eating away my spicy uttapam; I was thinking – how well this reserved manager knows me!!! He delivers what I need, to the exact specification and requirement, time and again. But my friend; the very social manager is full of errors, full of mistakes and therefore full of excuses. He gets away easily, in spite of doing all these errors/mistakes because of his social skills. He keeps blaming the staff, process, his busy lifestyle, faulty machine, electricity, food he had last night for delivering: tea without sugar, uttapam not well cooked, or even coffee in stead of a tea sometime. But I like him. I am a good friend of him and I shall continue to go to Sharvana Bhawan or any other restaurant he works for in the future, because of our friendship. I know nothing he does is intentional but he that’s how he is. But look at the reserved manager – hardly has he done any mistake. He is fully conscious. He may not have social skills and may not know many customers as my friend but whoever he knows, he knows them well and his customers can trust him to deliver right things to them, every time. To get a better/appropriate service, we don't need to know the service provider.
Their working style reminds me to a management style; which we see very often in the IT industry. A management style which is planned, thought through or a management style while is unplanned, which is popularly known as “Agile management”. The main difference between agile and traditional/planned management is that agile management completes small portions of the deliverables in each delivery cycle (iteration) while traditional methods evolve the entire set of deliverables over time, completing them near the end of the project.
Agile management is definitely not my favourite approach. I always thought it is being easily exploited and it rarely works to the hype it has created in the recent past. Places/Management with some deficiencies/intention; often are attracted to agile management. I always have experienced cheating, exploitation, sense of uncertainty during course of every agile based example. A good friend of mine; tried to explain the difference when I went to him to understand the subject better. This is what he said:
“Custom / bespoke software development can be compared with going to a special restaurant and asking to prepare dinner specifically for you (not picking from predefined menu). Make cocktails which are in the list and at the end of the evening you are getting the bill. It might be bigger than you expected, but all the food is consumed.
As learning, there is 2 major scheme of work in custom development world:
And based on my experience 95% of the projects end up having the same budget spend regardless the agreed scheme. Fixed price projects end-up to have to have round of paid change requests, while dedicated development is speedier, because you can introduce changes earlier. “
What are you thoughts? I am still not convinced. All it matters to me when I am acting as a customer or a service provider is effectiveness-effectiveness-effectiveness. That is the only thing drives financial and non-financial success in long term. Everything is short term and I don’t need to explain what the destination of short-termism is. Yes; initially it is very appealing.
When we deliver the best, what we supposed to deliver; then there is no scope for argument, no scope for excuses, no scope for demand, and no scope for cheating. Let’s ask these questions to find our decisive answer:
All these shortfalls can not go (ALWAYS) as attributes of Agile Management. If they do; then were we not better off with traditional management (which is planned and thought through)? OLD IS GOLD they say. And like my friend said; based on his experience 95% of the projects end up having the same budget spend regardless the agreed scheme . If that is the case; is “Agile Management” worth the pressure/uncertainty/trouble? Agile management has to rise beyond these points to make it a truly appealing and enduring management technique.